Porter - Competitive Forces and Generic Strategies
Michael Porter
argues that businesses must respond to five competitive forces
- the threat of new entrants
- the bargaining power of suppliers
- threats from substitute products or services
- the bargaining power of buyers
- rivalry amongst existing firms
He recommends three generic strategies to out-perform competitors or
maintain a market position against competition.
- Overall Cost Leadership
- produce the same/better quality at less cost than anyone else. Enjoy
greater profits or - in a price war - stay in the market, profitably, with reduced prices.
This may revolutionise a firm where industry competition has been sluggish. Competitors may be ill-prepared - mentally, economically, operationally - to minimise costs e.g. steel, retail banking, lager, an in-patient day.
- Differentiation
- implies a better/different product/service (or perceived as different) from others. With differentiated quality as the target - do we ignore
costs?
Quality imperatives demand a strategy equating the product with
"desirable" quality standards. Differentiation can earn above average
profits even in slow growth or declining market.
- Market
Niche/Segmentation - focusing on
- a section or group of the buying public
or
- a segment of a product line
or
- an area of a geographic market
Premise - we can service a narrow target more effectively than rivals who compete more broadly. Low cost and differentiation will still be required for the niche.
The Porter recommendation is to avoid getting caught
in the middle
Do not lose sight of strategies B and C because A
is chosen. Strategy is not something to look at in isolation. It must satisfy
as many aspects of the business as possible - short and long term . Take the
business as a whole.
References and Further Reading
Davis and Lemke: The Role of Luck in Strategic Performance
Written by Chris Jarvis for the BOLA project